Nishmat's Women’s Health and HalachaIn memory of Chaya Mirel bat R' Avraham

  • Hebrew
  • English
  • Espnaol
  • Francais
  • donate

Learning to evaluate stains (2)

1 March, 2006


In response to the answer I received:

1. Most women go to their local Orthodox rabbi to get a psak on nidda stains. Did all these rabbis really do that much training in this particular area?

2. Isn’t there a textbook of some sort that could help women learn this – at least to a greater extent than most women do now? It seems like a very inefficient (and potentially problematic) system. And if I do want to get this training in determining stains, why isn’t more readily available? It just seems strange to me that this information is so inaccessible to women, when it’s entirely about them.

3. The fact that there’s so much contradictory information about which stains are actually problematic makes me wonder why it’s taken so seriously. If it isn’t actually rooted on any shared tradition or objective facts, why is this such a major issue if it isn’t kept meticulously? Why would I keep one tradition over another and why would I trust my local rabbi?

P.S. I am currently in the process of deciding whether to observe these laws or not. I truly appreciate your time in answering my questions, as there are few people who are qualified or willing to respond.


1. Yes, rabbis and yoatzot who answer questions regarding stains and discharges on bedikot must do extensive training. There are community rabbis whose training is not as extensive, and they often consult with their own rabbis when they are unsure. More than anything, practice and practical experience in this field is what gives them the tools to asses the different colors. Certainly in the training programs to become the rabbi of a community a lot of emphasis should be put on this area of halacha.

2. As mentioned in our previous answer, the problem with bedikot is that there is much debate about the halachic status of certain colors, and there are different traditions concerning those colors. It would be presumptuous to codify in a book one specific tradition regarding these colors, as this would ignore and disregard the other traditions. This would be similar to teaching a halacha according to Sephardi ruling, while disregarding that there is a parallel but different Ashkenazi ruling. Another reason is the complex nature of ruling regarding colors, which requires practical experience. Training usually involves working with a single rabbi and becoming familiar with his tradition regarding different colors. Factors other than the color itself are also taken into account.  Another problem with printing a color chart would be that the colors could change in printing itself or fade over time.

3. The information about different situations in which a stain is found are pretty straightforward, though there are differences of opinion and different rulings as in most areas of halacha. The colors are a bigger problem, as traditions in this regard are transmitted orally and dependant on the judgment made by eyesight of different rabbis. Ruling in halacha is not an exact science, as the Torah was given to be kept by human beings, and its rulings intended to be determined by our human capabilities. That said, Judaism takes tradition very seriously. We are unable to trace back the sources of all traditions and determine which is correct, due to the unfortunate dispersion of the Jewish people over the years. It is also unclear that we are meant to find the “correct” tradition, rather than respect the fact that the Torah can be interpreted in different ways. It is important to find a halachic authority to whom one may consistently ask questions, but that authority should be one that the couple (or individual) relate to and can speak with frankly.

We commend your sincere search for answers to these important questions. Many women who observe the laws of niddah deal with the same issues, and we will be happy for you to continue using this resource to ask. We were sorry to hear that you are unable to find an address to speak with directly. If you would like to tell us where you live, perhaps we can try to get you in touch with someone who is sensitive to the issues you have raised, at least by phone if not in person.

We wish you much hatzlacha in your continued search of your Jewish world.

This internet service does not preclude, override or replace the psak of any rabbinical authority. It is the responsibility of the questioner to inform us of any previous consultation or ruling. As even slight variation in circumstances may have Halachic consequences, views expressed concerning one case may not be applied to other, seemingly similar cases. All health and health-related information contained within Nishmat's Women's Health & Halacha Web site is intended to be general in nature and should not be used as a substitute for consulting with your health care professional. The advice is intended to offer a basis for individuals to discuss their medical condition with their health care provider but not individual advice. Although every effort is made to ensure that the material within Nishmat's Women's Health & Halacha Web site is accurate and timely, it is provided for the convenience of the Web site user but should not be considered official. Advice for actual medical practice should be obtained from a licensed health care professional.

For further questions or comments: 

The Nishmat Women's Health and Halacha Site is a public service of Nishmat, The Jeanie Schottenstein Center for Advanced Torah Study for Women. This project and others like it are made possible by contributions from people like you. If you have benefited from the service, and wish to enable us to help others, click here to donate.

Users of Internet filtering services: This site discusses sensitive subjects that some services filter without visual indication. A page that appears 100% complete might actually be missing critical Jewish-law or medical information. To ensure that you view the pages accurately, ask the filtering service to whitelist all pages under

Accessibility Toolbar