In memory of Chaya Mirel bat R’ Avraham

In memory of Chaya Mirel bat R' Avraham

Less observant spouse, difficult transition after mikveh
December 7, 2004

Question

I recently got married. My husband comes from a totally non-religious background while I come from a modern orthodox family. We are having problems with the issue of taharat mishpacha. He agreed prior to our wedding that we would keep the laws according to my level. At the time that proposed level was total abstinence from sexual relations, rigorously doing the bedikot and going to the mikva, but frankly ignoring the harchakot. But when I had mikva classes just prior to our wedding I decided that this was not enough for me, and that we would keep the harchakot as well, including of course sleeping separately. My husband is finding this very difficult. Strangely enough (for me) his main problem is the first couple of days AFTER I have been to the mikva, not before. He says that he finds it impossible to “switch on” his desire for me just because I am now “available”. This has resulted so far in a delay of a few days each time before we resume relations. I find this hugely frustrating, my expectation having been that mikva night would be a special experience for the both of us each month, as reported by many women. Not only that of course, but the total days left us to is not huge!
Is there anyone out there with a similar experience? Any advice for us? I desperately want to keep this mitzva properly. Please help.

Answer

Mazal tov on your recent marriage!

The laws of niddah invite a couple to build their relationship in both physical and non-physical ways, and the period of physical separation and reunion on mikveh night can create excitement in a marriage. Nevertheless, these transitions also can prove difficult for many couples. Sometimes, couples have the expectation that you expressed, that mikveh will be special, and are surprised to find that observing harchakot during niddah fosters emotional distance that doesn’t automatically dissipate after mikveh for one or both spouses.

The first step to solving most problems that arise is to communicate. If husband and wife can share expectations, frustrations, and personal challenges, they are often able to find a solution together. Sometimes, just acknowledging the difficulty can make a difference.

If transitioning back to physical intimacy is difficult, you may be able to find ways to maintain your non-physical closeness and build communication skills during the niddah period that help ease the transition. You might spend time together in permissible ways (for example, going on a date) over the day or two prior to mikveh night, in order to build anticipation.

To make mikveh night special and help you reconnect, you may also find it helpful to plan a special evening together for when you return from the mikveh. Sexual relations are halachically encouraged on mikveh night. However, this can sometimes create pressure or stress, so it’s permissible for a couple to agree to spend the time reconnecting through touch or other intimate actions and see where things go, without necessarily having relations.

Building the intimate relationship and its halachic patterns takes time and requires patience and sensitivity. These halachot can prove challenging for anyone, and it is especially challenging when the members of the couple have different approaches to Halacha in general. In your case, your spouse is also grappling with unanticipated changes shortly before your wedding.

We recommend that the two of you seek ways to work together on these issues and to develop a framework for religious decision-making in areas that concern your relationship to each other. You may find it useful to learn more about these halachot together. You might also benefit from a conversation with an appropriate, understanding halachic professional, and possibly seek professional counseling. Seeking assistance is a sign of strength and commitment for a couple, not of failure.

Please contact us if we can be of further assistance or if you would like to speak with a Yoetzet Halacha. B’hatzlacha!

This response was updated on 20 November, 2022.
Facebook
WhatsApp
Email

Yoatzot Halacha: Answering Women’s Halachic Questions

 Appreciate Yoatzot Halacha?

Support our work & allow your donation to make a difference.

Accessibility Toolbar

Welcome to Our New Site!

We’re still in the process of bringing over our full archive of Q&As. Stay with us as we continue to update all our content and features.
Thank you for your patience, and please feel free to share feedback or let us know if you’re looking for something specific.