In memory of Chaya Mirel bat R’ Avraham

In memory of Chaya Mirel bat R' Avraham

Niddah/Zavah cycle: Rambam vs. Ramban
August 9, 2006

Question

Was mainstream practice to follow Rambam or Ramban in interpretation of the 7/11 cycle – i.e. continuously from first menstruation or anew each month? If it was Rambam, is this a reason the bnot Israel took on the extra days, because counting was so difficult? (I know they were before Rambam, but perhaps they followed the same shita). If the Ramban were the mainstream, why would bnot Israel have taken on the humra – it is not so hard to count starting with 7 days of niddah each month.

Are there any other repercussions to this machloket or reasons to introduce Rambam or explain him if his view is/was not mainstream (i.e. in the Middle Ages)?

Answer

The Ramban's explanation was accepted, largely because it is difficult to be sure of what the Rambam really meant and how it would work in practice. The difficulties of counting on a d'orayta level, even according to Ramban, were compounded by the lack of expertise in assessing which colors of blood rendered a woman temeiah and which did not. A woman could bleed six days, thinking she had gone through six days of niddah when in fact she only began having blood that would render her niddah on day five. Counting and differentiating between niddah and zavah days would thus be more difficult. There could also be an issue in assessing zavah days with blood that was seen bein hashmashot.

The Rambam's view is most interesting on a theoretical level and in order to bring into relief the implications of the Ramban's view (for example, that one cannot be a niddah and zavah simultaneously). We would not recommend getting into the precise details unless teaching in great depth.
Facebook
WhatsApp
Email

Yoatzot Halacha: Answering Women’s Halachic Questions

 Appreciate Yoatzot Halacha?

Support our work & allow your donation to make a difference.

Accessibility Toolbar

Welcome to Our New Site!

We’re still in the process of bringing over our full archive of Q&As. Stay with us as we continue to update all our content and features.
Thank you for your patience, and please feel free to share feedback or let us know if you’re looking for something specific.